close

Town of Fort Myers Beach Council votes to appoint Cereceda as next mayor

Allers had served as mayor since 2022 election

By Nathan Mayberg 4 min read
1 / 35
2 / 35
Fort Myers Beach Mayor Anita Cereceda. Photo by Nathan Mayberg
3 / 35
4 / 35
5 / 35
6 / 35
7 / 35
8 / 35
9 / 35
10 / 35
11 / 35
12 / 35
13 / 35
14 / 35
15 / 35
16 / 35
17 / 35
Tom Brady was appointed as vice mayor of the town council. Photo by Nathan Mayberg
18 / 35
19 / 35
20 / 35
Fort Myers Beach Mayor Anita Cereceda and Town Clerk Amy Baker
21 / 35
22 / 35
23 / 35
24 / 35
25 / 35
26 / 35
27 / 35
28 / 35
29 / 35
30 / 35
31 / 35
32 / 35
33 / 35
34 / 35
35 / 35

The Town of Fort Myers Beach has a new mayor. Anita Cereceda was appointed by the newly-sworn Town Council as the next mayor this morning, replacing Dan Allers. Councilmembers Tom Brady and Rebecca Link backed Cereceda in voting for her. Brady was named vice mayor, replacing Scott Safford. Safford nominated Allers for mayor. Allers accepted the nomination but was outvoted. Cereceda was the town’s first mayor after incorporation and served again as mayor during the end of a two-term stint that ended in 2020 after she was term-limited. Cereceda, Link and Brady were voted into four-year terms on Nov. 3.

The Town of Fort Myers Beach Council’s vote to elect Cereceda as the town’s next mayor followed debate between the councilmembers over how the appointment procedure and vote should take place, following guidelines from the town attorney leaving the procedures in the council’s hands. Each year, the Town Council votes to appoint a mayor. Cereceda replaced Dan Allers, who had been serving as mayor since 2022. Cereceda earned three votes to be the next mayor, while Allers had two votes.

The election of Cereceda, Brady and Link were seen as a statement by the town’s voters on the pace of development after Hurricane Ian and the approval of large-scale projects that have needed numerous deviations from the Town Council. Cereceda was previously the chair of the Local Planning Agency, where she voted against the controversial Seagate Development Group’s 17-story condo tower project. The Town Council voted to approve the project in 2024, leading to the formation of Protect FMB. Brady, president of Protect FMB, helped lead a legal challenge to the Town Council’s approval of the project. Cereceda supported Protect FMB and their unsuccessful efforts to reverse the Town Council’s decision.

A recall election in 2025 saw Link earn the most votes, dislodging former Councilmember Karen Woodson. Brady was the second-largest vote-getter in that election, but his election was put on hold after a county judge found that recall petitions for former Councilmember John King were invalid. King kept his seat before deciding not to run for re-election. Former Councilmember John McLean, who was appointed by the Town Council in February to replace former Councilmember Jim Atterholt, also decided not to seek re-election after initially filing to be on the ballot.

Brady, Cereceda and Link were ultimately elected to four-year terms earlier this month after defeating Ed Schoonover for the three seats up for grabs.

Brady said “I believe my election to the Town Council reaffirms Fort Myers Beach voters’ support for our Strategic Plan, Comprehensive Plan, and Land Development Code. I am guided by the needs of our community as a whole, not any single interest on the island. I am hopeful about our future and confident that, working together, we can continue our recovery from Hurricane Ian while preserving the culture, character, and lifestyle that make our island special.”

Brady said he will bring an “independent voice, practical leadership, and a commitment to follow through. My experience in government, and business has taught me to listen, ask difficult questions, manage resources responsibly, and bring people together to solve problems.”

Brady said he would support redevelopment “that respects our island’s character, and ensuring our development rules are clear and consistently applied. I will work with my fellow Council members to build consensus, spend taxpayer dollars carefully, and keep residents informed.

“People can count on me to do my homework, explain my decisions, and remain accessible,” Brady said. “I’m grateful for the trust my supporters have placed in me, and my responsibility now is to listen to and serve the entire island.”