County commissioners discuss Amendment 3 fallout
Lee County commissioners are considering a hiring freeze as well as potential cuts to departments to starting making up for a tax revenue deficit expected to be more than $130 million next year, and as much as $176 million or more in 2028 due to the passage of the Amendment 3 state referendum. Previous estimates by the county had put the lost revenue for the first year a little lower though much higher at about $240 million for the second year.
The vote by Florida residents to increase the homestead property exemption on local municipal government taxes from $50,000 of property value to $150,000 in year one, and up to $250,000 in year two, will create a crater in the budgets of Lee County and other local governments.
Based on preliminary estimates by county officials, there may need to be 15-20% reductions to county departments due to the lost revenue.
Lee County Manager Dave Harner proposed a hiring freeze at a workshop of county commissioners on Monday, though he suggested the hiring freeze should not extend to several departments due to their revenue sources not being from taxes. Harner suggested exempting the department of solid waste and utilities, the department of transportation, parks and recreation, and permitting.
Harner also wants to exempt a freeze on hiring as related to EMS and 911 calltakers, though he supports a hiring freeze for other public safety departments.
“That will effect service relatively soon,” Harner said. Harner said the hiring freeze could start immediately or Dec. 1, based on the will of the commissioners.
Harner said the direct service impacts of the hiring freeze could result in longer transit times for buses, as well as limited hours for parks and libraries.
Harner has not yet formulated an estimate on the savings that would result from the hiring freeze though he said it would be substantial. The county currently has about 80 unfilled positions.
About 60% of the county’s budget covers the Lee County Sheriff’s Office, Lee County Clerk’s Office, county court system, property appraiser’s office, tax collector’s office and supervisor of elections. Those departments are known as constitutional, in that the departments themselves are required by state law. While the departments are mandated, the county manager’s office also said there are no limitations as to what can be cut.
According to the county manager’s office, there is no limitation as to what can be cut in the budget.
Lee County District 1 Commissioner Kevin Ruane said he wants the county attorney’s office to address the commissioners and explain what the county is required to do and not do based on Amendment 3.
Ruane wants clarity on which jobs are essential and required, and which jobs are not mandatory. Ruane wants to develop a want list and a need list.
“There are going to be on items that we are going to talk to that may be sensitive,” he said.
Ruane said he also wants to hear from the public.
Lee County District 4 Commissioner Brian Hamman said affordability issues are key to why Amendment 3 passed. “We understand the assignment,” Hamman said.
Hamman compared the county’s challenge to a family needing to cut their own spending based on less income. Hamman said the county will have to do what a family under budget constraints would need to do: sell the family boat, cut out Netflix, find a cheaper cell phone plan and “cutting your own grass.”
Hamman said he wants a line-by-line budget review process that will leave the county with a budget “of necessities,” and then figure out which “luxuries” the county can afford.
To reach Nathan Mayberg, please email nmayberg@breezenewspapers.com