Matanzas on the Bay to reopen as “On the Bay” in October

1 / 10

Matanzas on the Bay, will reopen in early October on Fort Myers Beach, its owners announced. File photo by Nathan Mayberg

2 / 10

Ed Fino (left to right), Phil Gandolfo, Marianne Gandolfo and Joanne Fino enjoy a night out on the patio next to Matanzas on the Bay. Photo by Nathan Mayberg

3 / 10

Matanzas on the Bay. File photo

4 / 10

A view from “Petey’s Upper Deck” overlooking the first-floor seating area outside of Matanzas on the Bay with a perfect view of Matanzas Pass. NATHAN MAYBERG

5 / 10

Matanzas on the Bay. File photo

6 / 10

Tami and Rich Kincaid (front) with their friends Tami and Brad Moore (rear) at Petey's Upper Deck on Fort Myers Beach. Photo by Nathan Mayberg

7 / 10

A group of friends from Michigan enjoying a night out at Petey's Upper Deck on Fort Myers Beach. Photo by Nathan Mayberg

8 / 10

Petey's Upper Deck Fort Myers Beach. Photo by Nathan Mayberg

9 / 10

Petey's Upper Deck, above Matanzas on the Bay, reopened in 2023 after Hurricane Ian. File photo

10 / 10

Petey's Upper Deck and its popular pizza at Matanzas on the Bay could open as soon as next week, co-owner Doug Speirn-Smith said. File photo

[expand]

close

Matanzas on the Bay, which has been closed since Hurricane Ian, will reopen under new management and ownership in early October under the new name “On the Bay.”

The owners of the restaurant, who bought the property in 2023, have continued to operate Petey’s Upper Deck, the casual pizza restaurant upstairs. They have also set up some tables and seating downstairs overlooking the bay.

The iconic restaurant, which has been operating since the 1970’s, was purchased as part of a $7.5 million land deal.

Known for its fresh-from-the-Gulf menu, its new owners said in an announcement that guests “can expect the same charm that has made it a community icon for decades.”

The menu will once highlight local seafood, including Gulf shrimp and fresh catch dishes, alongside signature items that regulars have missed. But with a new look comes new creations from Chef Jose Rivera.

With live music scheduled every day, On the Bay will bring back its signature blend of great food, great views, and lively entertainment.

“We’ve completed extensive renovations on the restaurant. On the Bay has always been about more than just dining. It’s a place where people gather, celebrate, and make memories by the water,” said General Manager Eddie Parisi.

Private party spaces will also be available for groups looking for a waterfront setting to host events, meetings, and celebrations.

The restaurant is located at 416 Crescent Street on Fort Myers Beach.