close

Kilwins returns to Fort Myers Beach

Ice cream and fudge shop has new home on Old San Carlos Boulevard

By Nathan Mayberg 4 min read
1 / 35
2 / 35
3 / 35
4 / 35
5 / 35
6 / 35
7 / 35
8 / 35
Beth and Justin Huttie at the new Kilwins on Fort Myers Beach. Photo by Nathan Mayberg
9 / 35
10 / 35
11 / 35
12 / 35
13 / 35
14 / 35
15 / 35
16 / 35
17 / 35
18 / 35
19 / 35
20 / 35
21 / 35
22 / 35
23 / 35
24 / 35
25 / 35
26 / 35
27 / 35
28 / 35
29 / 35
30 / 35
31 / 35
32 / 35
33 / 35
34 / 35
35 / 35

Kilwins, the ice cream shop that once occupied a storefront at Times Square before it was destroyed by Hurricane Ian, has returned to Fort Myers Beach with new owners at a new location.

The store opened on Monday at Old San Carlos Boulevard where a sushi restaurant once stood.

The popular fudge and chocolate dessert specialists have new franchise ownership in Beth and Justin Huttie. The couple moved here from Tampa to run the shop.

The hours are tentatively set to be 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. for the first week, and will be 9 a.m. to 10 p.m. on weekdays and 9 a.m. to 11 a.m. on weekends once they get their expresso machine in.

Company statistics showed them that expresso in the mornings was a big hit at the old Kilwins, Mr. Huttie said. “They sold a lot of coffee in the mornings,” he said.

Company data also told them that fudge sales were high at the old store. A soft opening on Sunday confirmed this, with about 60 slices of fudge being sold over just a few hours, Huttie said.

Huttie said some of the people who came into the shop on Sunday were “very emotional.” Huttie said one Fort Myers Beach woman who is in the middle of rebuilding her home, visited Sunday and was “in tears” at the sight of the new Kilwin’s.

“There were a lot of ‘thank-you’s,'” Mrs. Huttie said.

The new Kilwins has 64 flavors of ice cream, and if the taste of customers from the old Fort Myers Beach Kilwins holds true, vanilla toasted coconut ice cream will be the top seller. Other expected top sellers include vanilla sea salt caramel, and Superman ice cream for kids. The Superman flavor of fruity pink, yellow and blue ice cream nearly sold out Sunday.

The 64 flavors of ice cream includes three flavors of sorbeto. The sorbeto flavors are lemon, mango and rasberry They can display 32 flavors of ice cream at a time.

The Hutties make their own chocolate fudge, waffle bowls and waffle cones at the store. A fudge machine is used to dip the waffle cones into at a customer’s request.

Another treat they offer is a sunset cooler sorbeto, which features lemon sorbeto mixed with sprite and topped with rasberry sorbeto.

You can also get a milkshake, sundae, cappuccino or coffee.

This is first foray into the ice cream and chocolate business for Mr. and Mrs. Huttie.

Mr. Huttie said when they did their research into finding a new location for Kilwins, they were asked by the company if they were interested in Fort Myers Beach. They found that visitors have an affinity for the old Fort Myers Beach, he said. “We are bringing in an old product back new,” Huttie said. “This was a perfect for it. We are excited to be here.”

The new store is about twice the size as the former Times Square shop, with 1,700 square feet and a large cooler in the back that allows them to hold hundreds of gallons worth of ice cream as backup.

Mr. Huttie said they received a special request for apple pie ice cream on Sunday, so he made a special order for three tubs of the flavor. Other interesting and unique Kilwins ice cream flavors he expects customers to enjoy is the Traverse City cherry from the Michigan-based company. The Georgia peach and Mackinac Island fudge are other flavors he hopes customers will dip into.

The Hutties also brought back five former employees from the old Kilwin’s back to work, including Zack Duckworth and his wife Amy. Zack and Amy lost their home on Fort Myers Beach to Hurricane Ian.

“It’s amazing to see all the previous customers come back and how happy they are that we are back on the beach,” Mr. Duckworth said. He said he is looking forward to leaving “a smile on the face” of customers again.